Stock options for employees in France: why U.S. plans need a French sub-plan

Stock options for employees in France: why U.S. plans need a French sub-plan

A U.S. company hires its first employees in Paris and wants to grant them options under its existing equity incentive plan. The plan was drafted for ISOs and NSOs under U.S. law. In France, applied as is, it may turn the option gain into ordinary salary subject to full social security contributions, for both the employee and the French employer. The usual fix is a French sub-plan that qualifies the options under French law.

This guide explains the French regime for stock options, how options are taxed and why a sub-plan matters. It flags the points Romain Waiss-Moreau coordinates with U.S. counsel.

French law organises stock options under Articles L. 225-177 et seq. of the Commercial Code. They can be:

  • subscription options, giving the right to newly issued shares; or
  • purchase options, over existing shares bought back by the company.

The regime applies to French SAs and SASs, listed or not, and, through the rules on group companies, to options granted by a foreign parent to employees of its French subsidiary when the plan complies with the French requirements. Options meeting these requirements are often called qualified options in France.

How are options taxed in France?

GainCalculationTreatment for options granted since 28 September 2012
Excess discountDiscount above 5% of share value at grantTaxed as salary at exercise
Acquisition gainShare value at exercise minus exercise priceTaxed under salary rules, with specific social contributions, upon sale of the shares (qualified options)
Capital gainSale price minus value at exerciseCapital gains regime

The French employer also pays a specific employer contribution on qualified options, generally based on their value at grant. Non-qualified options do not benefit from this framework: the gain is usually treated as employment income subject to ordinary social security contributions, which can be significantly more expensive.

What does a French sub-plan contain?

A French sub-plan is an appendix to the U.S. plan that applies only to French-resident participants. It aligns the U.S. terms with French requirements on, among others:

  • eligible beneficiaries: employees and certain officers of the issuer or its group companies;
  • exercise price: not set below legal minimums, with no excess discount;
  • holding and transfer restrictions compatible with French rules;
  • adjustments on corporate events following French law;
  • employee communications in French and data protection compliance.

The plan also needs to fit French employment law, especially on termination: forfeiture clauses must not operate as a prohibited financial penalty. Romain Waiss-Moreau drafts sub-plans in coordination with the group's U.S. advisors, so that both sides remain consistent.

Stock options, BSPCE or free shares?

If the French company itself is eligible, BSPCE remain the most attractive option for its employees: no employer charges and a simpler tax regime. Free shares (attributions gratuites d'actions, similar to RSUs) are another qualified instrument, popular in larger groups. A U.S. parent granting RSUs to French employees also needs a French sub-plan for them to qualify.

What does each instrument cost the French employer?

InstrumentEmployer chargeTimingNotes
BSPCENoneNot applicableEligible companies only
Qualified stock optionsSpecific employer contributionAt grantDue even if never exercised
Qualified free shares (RSU-like)Specific employer contributionAt vestingExemptions for some SMEs
Non-qualified foreign plan optionsOrdinary social security contributionsDepending on treatment of the gainUsually the most expensive

This is why a French sub-plan almost always pays for itself once a group has several French employees.

Case study: a New York startup hiring in Paris

A U.S. startup opens a Paris office through a French SAS subsidiary and promises options to six hires. Its U.S. plan provides for NSOs priced on a 409A valuation, with full forfeiture on termination. The French sub-plan set a price compliant with French rules, adjusted the holding period, adapted the termination clause to French employment law, provided French-language information to participants and organised the subsidiary's social security reporting. The firm drafted the sub-plan with the company's U.S. counsel, keeping the plan consistent in both countries.

What happens on a sale of the company?

Plans usually provide for vesting acceleration or substitution of the options by options of the acquirer. For French participants, these changes must be checked against the qualified regime, since some modifications can cause the loss of favourable treatment.

Equity for French employees: key points

  • Granting under a U.S. plan without a sub-plan: the French social cost can be multiplied.
  • Pricing below the legal minimum: the excess discount is immediately taxable as salary.
  • Forgetting the employer contribution: it is due even if options are never exercised.

Frequently asked questions

Can a Delaware parent grant options to French employees directly?

Yes. The French sub-plan allows these options to be treated as qualified in France when the conditions on group relationships and plan terms are met.

Does the French employer have reporting obligations?

Yes. The employer must report grants, exercises and certain information to the tax authorities and to employees. The sub-plan and payroll process should be set up together.

What about 409A valuations?

A 409A valuation addresses U.S. tax rules. French rules apply separately to French residents. In practice, the U.S. fair market value is often used as the reference, but the French minimum price rules must be checked.

Do RSUs granted to French employees need a sub-plan too?

Yes. RSUs correspond to French free shares. Without a French sub-plan meeting the statutory requirements, they do not benefit from the qualified regime and are generally treated as ordinary employment income.