Software licence and SaaS agreements under French law: what U.S. vendors must change

Software licence and SaaS agreements under French law: what U.S. vendors must change

A U.S. software vendor signing its first French customer usually sends its standard master subscription agreement. Most of it will work. Some of it will not: French copyright law reads licences narrowly, certain user rights cannot be excluded, liability clauses are tested against the "essential obligation" doctrine, and the EU Data Act now imposes switching rights on cloud services. A software licence or SaaS agreement governed by, or performed in, France needs targeted adjustments.

This guide sets out those adjustments, from the vendor's and the customer's perspective, and flags where Romain Waiss-Moreau intervenes.

How does French law treat software?

Software is protected by copyright (droit d'auteur) under the French Intellectual Property Code. Three consequences matter in practice.

  • What is not granted is reserved. The author holds exclusive rights to reproduce, adapt and distribute the program (Article L. 122-6). A licence covers only what it expressly describes.
  • Assignments are formal. A transfer of rights must specify each right assigned and its scope in terms of extent, purpose, territory and duration (Article L. 131-3). Broad "all rights" language is fragile.
  • Ownership follows the author. Software created by an employee in the course of their duties belongs to the employer (Article L. 113-9). Code written by contractors does not: it requires a written assignment.

Which user rights cannot be excluded?

Article L. 122-6-1 of the Intellectual Property Code grants the lawful user certain rights that no contract can remove.

User rightCan the contract exclude it?
Making a backup copy where necessaryNo
Observing and testing the program to understand its underlying ideasNo
Decompiling, strictly to achieve interoperabilityNo, within the statutory limits
Correcting errorsYes, the vendor may reserve this right

A clause prohibiting all reverse engineering will be read down to the extent it conflicts with these rights.

Which SaaS clauses need adjusting for France?

  • Liability caps: valid in B2B, but Article 1170 of the Civil Code strikes out any clause that deprives the vendor's essential obligation of its substance. A cap set at a token amount for service unavailability is at risk.
  • Unilateral changes: on standard-form contracts, Article 1171 can void non-negotiable clauses creating a significant imbalance. Changes to price or functionality need notice and objective limits.
  • Data protection: a data processing agreement meeting Article 28 GDPR, plus a lawful mechanism for transfers to the United States.
  • Service levels: French customers expect measurable availability, response times and service credits.
  • Exit and portability: data return in a usable format and transition assistance.

What does the Data Act change for SaaS providers?

The EU Data Act has applied since 12 September 2025. Providers of cloud and SaaS services must remove obstacles to switching providers, including contractual, commercial and technical barriers. Contracts must set out switching procedures and timeframes, and switching charges are to be abolished from 12 January 2027. Standard U.S. agreements with long lock-in periods, punitive exit fees or no data export path need revision.

What makes a service level clause enforceable?

ElementExampleDrafting point
Availability99.5% per month, excluding scheduled maintenanceDefine measurement method and exclusions
Incident severityCritical, major, minorObjective criteria, not the vendor's sole judgement
Response time1 business hour for critical incidentsBusiness hours or 24/7
Resolution or workaround4 hours for critical incidentsDistinguish fixes from workarounds
Service credits5% of monthly fees per availability band missedState whether credits are the sole remedy

99.9% availability allows about 43 minutes of downtime per month; 99.5% allows more than three and a half hours. French enterprise buyers will negotiate these figures closely.

Case study: a U.S. vendor's first French enterprise customer

A U.S. HR software vendor signs a French retail group. The customer's procurement team rejects the vendor's standard agreement on four points: a liability cap equal to one month of fees, a right to change features without notice, an exit clause with no data export, and U.S. data hosting without a transfer mechanism. The negotiated version sets a cap tied to twelve months of fees, with higher limits for data breaches; requires notice and no material reduction of functionality; adds data export in a standard format and transition assistance, in line with the Data Act; and documents transfers under the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework with standard contractual clauses as a fallback. The firm prepares a French-law addendum that vendors can reuse across customers rather than renegotiating each contract from scratch.

How should open source be handled?

Open source components come with their own licences. Permissive licences (MIT, Apache, BSD) impose few constraints. Copyleft licences such as the GPL can require disclosure of source code depending on how the software is distributed. French customers increasingly request an open source inventory as part of due diligence.

Adapting your software contracts: key points

  • Relying on implied licence scope: under French law, unclear scope is resolved in favour of the author, which can leave customers without rights they assumed they had.
  • Overlooking contractor code: without written assignments, the vendor may not own what it licenses.
  • Keeping U.S. exit terms: lock-in and exit fees now collide with the Data Act.

Frequently asked questions

Can I keep New York law in my agreement with French customers?

In B2B, yes. EU and French mandatory rules, including the GDPR and the Data Act, still apply. Choosing a law that the customer's courts must apply with expert evidence also makes disputes slower and costlier.

Is a SaaS agreement a licence?

Not primarily. French courts treat SaaS as a service contract, which may include a limited right of access and use. The qualification affects warranties, liability and tax treatment.

Should we offer source code escrow?

Large French customers often request it for business-critical software. Define the release events precisely and keep the deposit updated with each major version.

Does the Data Act apply to U.S. SaaS providers?

Yes, when they provide data processing services to customers in the EU. Its switching rules apply regardless of where the provider is established.