Liquidation preference and preferred shares in French companies: 1x explained

Liquidation preference and preferred shares in French companies: 1x explained

U.S. investors are used to preferred stock with a 1x non-participating liquidation preference as the market standard. The same economics exist in France, through actions de préférence (preferred shares) issued by an SAS or SA. The concept travels well; the drafting does not always, because French law requires the rights to be set out in the bylaws and tested against rules such as the prohibition of leonine clauses.

This guide explains French preferred shares, the mechanics of the 1x preference and its variants, with worked examples. It flags the points Romain Waiss-Moreau addresses when U.S. term sheets are implemented in French companies.

What are French preferred shares?

Under Articles L. 228-11 et seq. of the French Commercial Code, a joint-stock company can issue shares with special rights of any kind: liquidation preference, priority dividend, enhanced or no voting rights, information rights, anti-dilution protection. They are created by extraordinary shareholders' decision, generally on the report of a special auditor when they benefit named persons, and their rights must be described in the bylaws. SARLs cannot issue preferred shares.

How does a 1x liquidation preference work?

On a liquidity event (sale, merger, liquidation), the preferred holder first receives one times its investment before the remaining proceeds are shared.

  • Non-participating: the investor receives the greater of its preference amount or its pro rata share of the proceeds.
  • Participating: the investor receives its preference, then also shares pro rata in the remainder.
  • Capped participating: participation stops once the investor has received a set multiple of its investment.

What does it mean in numbers?

Example: an investor has invested €2 million for 20% of the company.

Exit priceNon-participating: investorNon-participating: othersParticipating: investorParticipating: others
€3m€2m€1m€2.2m€0.8m
€5m€2m€3m€2.6m€2.4m
€20m€4m€16m€5.6m€14.4m

With a non-participating preference, the protection matters only in disappointing exits. With a participating preference, the investor takes more at every exit price.

What should be negotiated?

  • The multiple: 1x is standard in France as in the U.S.
  • Participation: non-participating is the norm in venture deals; participation should be capped if conceded.
  • Seniority between rounds: pari passu or stacked, with later rounds paid first.
  • Definition of the liquidity event: precise enough to exclude intra-group reorganisations.
  • Consistency between the bylaws, the shareholders' agreement and the waterfall clause.

Romain Waiss-Moreau models the distribution under several exit scenarios before signing, and ensures the U.S. term sheet translates accurately into French bylaws.

What other rights can preferred shares carry?

RightEffectFrequency in venture deals
Liquidation preferencePriority on exit proceedsAlmost always
Broad-based weighted average anti-dilutionAdjusts entry price in a down roundCommon
Full ratchet anti-dilutionResets entry price to the down-round priceRare, very founder-unfriendly
Class voting rightsConsent required for certain decisionsCommon
Priority dividendPriority on distributionsRare in startups
ConversionInto ordinary shares, notably on an IPOAlways

Case study: comparing two Series A term sheets

A startup receives two offers for the same €3 million investment. The first values the company at €12 million pre-money with a 1x participating preference; the second at €10 million pre-money with a 1x non-participating preference. On a €25 million exit, founders receive more under the second offer despite the lower valuation, because participation in the first offer more than offsets the valuation gap. The firm runs this comparison before founders choose their lead investor.

How are preferred shares created in France?

By an extraordinary shareholders' decision amending the bylaws to describe the new class. When issued to named persons, a special auditor reports on the particular benefits. Any later change to the rights requires the consent of the special meeting of the holders of that class.

Preferred shares: key points

  • Focusing on valuation alone: a participating preference can offset a high headline valuation.
  • Stacking preferences round after round: founders may receive nothing below a certain exit price.
  • Describing rights only in the agreement: preferred share rights must be in the bylaws.

Frequently asked questions

Is a liquidation preference compatible with the ban on leonine clauses?

Yes, when it organises the order of distribution without excluding any shareholder from all profits. Careful drafting remains necessary.

Do preferred shares in France convert into ordinary shares?

They can, under conditions set in the bylaws, for example automatically on an IPO or at the holder's option. Conversion terms must be specified at issuance.

Can the preferences be removed in a later round?

Yes, by an extraordinary decision of all shareholders and a decision of the special meeting of the relevant preferred holders, which means their consent is needed.

What is an anti-dilution clause?

It protects the investor if the company later raises at a lower valuation, by granting additional shares to offset all or part of the drop. The broad-based weighted average version is the most common and the most balanced.