Tag-along rights: protecting minority shareholders when a founder sells

Tag-along rights: protecting minority shareholders when a founder sells

A majority founder finds a buyer willing to pay a premium for their shares. Minority investors risk being left behind, with a new controlling shareholder they did not choose and no exit of their own. The tag-along right (droit de sortie conjointe) allows them to join the sale on the same terms as the selling shareholder.

This guide explains the variants of the clause, its triggers, the meaning of "same terms" and the procedure, with the points Romain Waiss-Moreau addresses in French shareholders' agreements involving U.S. investors.

What is a tag-along right?

A tag-along clause obliges a shareholder who intends to sell shares to procure that the buyer also acquires, on the same terms, the shares of the other shareholders who wish to sell. If the buyer refuses, the seller must abandon the sale or buy those shares themselves. It is a right for the beneficiaries, not an obligation, which distinguishes it from a drag-along.

Full or proportional tag-along?

VariantTriggerEffect
Full tag-alongTransfer resulting in a change of controlBeneficiaries may sell all their shares
Proportional tag-alongAny transfer by a designated shareholder, usually a founderBeneficiaries sell the same proportion of their shares as the seller

The full version protects against a change of control. The proportional version protects against partial founder sales: if a founder sells 20% of their holding, each beneficiary can sell 20% of theirs. Investors often ask for both.

How does the procedure work?

  • Notice by the seller: buyer's identity, number of shares, price and terms.
  • Exercise period: typically 15 to 30 days for beneficiaries to elect to sell.
  • Cut-back: if the buyer will not buy all shares offered, quantities are reduced pro rata under the agreed formula.
  • Completion: simultaneous sale by the seller and the electing beneficiaries.

The tag-along usually operates after the right of first refusal: if the other shareholders do not pre-empt the shares, the tag-along applies to the third-party sale.

What does "same terms" mean?

Equal treatment is the core of the clause, but it raises practical questions:

  • price per share is the same, subject to the waterfall between share classes;
  • warranties: financial investors usually refuse business warranties, which should be addressed upfront;
  • side benefits to the seller, such as a consulting agreement or an earn-out, can be a disguised price and should be included in the comparison.

Romain Waiss-Moreau drafts these definitions to prevent a seller from routing value outside the share price.

Worked example: proportional tag-along and cut-back

A founder holds 600,000 shares and wants to sell 120,000 (20%) at €5. An investor with a proportional tag-along holds 300,000 shares.

ScenarioFounder sellsInvestor sells
Buyer agrees to buy the investor's shares in addition120,00060,000 (20% of 300,000)
Buyer only wants 120,000 shares in total80,00040,000

In the second scenario, the cut-back shares the 120,000 shares pro rata, two-thirds and one-third. Without a precise cut-back formula, this common scenario becomes a dispute.

In which order do transfer clauses apply?

  • Notice of the proposed transfer to all beneficiaries.
  • Right of first refusal: shareholders may buy first.
  • Tag-along: if not pre-empted, beneficiaries may join the sale.
  • Approval of the buyer by the competent body, if required.
  • Completion on the notified terms.

The agreement should coordinate these steps with compatible deadlines, so that a sale can close within weeks.

Case study: a founder's secondary sale to a fund

A founder sells 15% of his shares to a secondary fund for personal liquidity. Seed angels exercise their proportional tag-along, which the fund had not budgeted for. The deal was restructured: the fund increased its overall commitment and the price per share was adjusted for everyone. The firm advises identifying tag-along beneficiaries before discussions with any buyer begin.

Tag-along clauses: key points

  • Ignoring indirect transfers: the sale of a holding company that owns the shares should trigger the clause.
  • Leaving warranties unaddressed: the deal may fail if minority sellers refuse what the buyer requires.
  • Overlooking side benefits: extra consideration to the seller undermines equal treatment.

Frequently asked questions

How is a breach of the tag-along enforced in France?

If the clause is only in the shareholders' agreement, the remedy is mainly damages. Mirroring it in the SAS bylaws and combining it with an approval clause gives much stronger protection, because a non-compliant transfer is then exposed to being voided.

Is a tag-along still useful if there is a drag-along?

Yes. The drag-along lets a majority force a full sale; the tag-along protects minorities in all other situations.

Are transfers within a group covered?

Usually not. Agreements allow permitted transfers to affiliates or personal holding companies, provided the transferee joins the agreement.

Does tag-along apply to sales between existing shareholders?

It depends on the drafting. Agreements often exclude transfers between existing shareholders, unless they result in a change of control.